- Some background: I stumbled across the cover of this Haggard and Nelson tune "Reasons to Quit" by the group Phosphorescent, and I've now listened to both versions about eighty-nine times since last week. I mean, it's a gorgeous country song. Check out the original here.
- Now, I don't smoke and I'm a really light drinker, but this song gets to me on another level--as a novelist. Often, I'm thinking, "I should quit writing novels. Not worth it." And so yeah, the song is right in tune with my latest round of thinking that way. Why am I bothering?
- Let's try it from this angle: I play guitar. More often when I was a teenager because I was in the high school jazz band and I had some friends who wanted a band, too. Actually, my very first band was guys I played AD&D with, and I ended up pissing them off about rehearsing rather than going to play D&D in the woods, so they all pretty much dumped me. but later on, I found some more guys to play rock and roll with (and I also quit playing AD&D). And I played some in church for a while, but then, I didn't have a band anymore. I found out that I preferred playing with other people, for other people, rather than just for myself. Also, I sang like shit and I was kind of shy, too, so that didn't help me in front of crowds.
- Even more so than playing music in a band, I really really really enjoyed recording on my little 4-track home studio. I had a synth for drumbeats and basslines and other wild stuff, and I would double the guitars, try to make them sound unique, do vocal harmonies, all sorts of fun. And those recordings, I had no trouble playing those for people. I wanted them to hear the stuff I did in the studio even more than live. But, you know, I didn't get any interest from the music biz folks when I sent it around. And after a while I just, you know, got tired of doing all this cool stuff that only I was listening to.
- I've pretty much wanted to be a novelist from the moment I finished reading my first one. Apart from some side-trips here and there over the years (comic book writer, rock star, songwriter, I even took the LSAT test once), I stuck with it and eventually got there, about to publish my seventh novel next month.
- But holy shit, it was hard to get there. And in the writing world, I'm a real small-timer. Small presses, e-presses, one self-pubbed e-book. I never got that contract with one of the NYC big publishers like my writing heroes. I mean, I'm happy that I've got some readers and I've done okay, especially with e-books, but I wanted people to buy my books the way I bought James Lee Burke's books--in hardcover on publication day.
- And yes, I know the whole "James Lee Burke, 109 rejections, but it won the Pulitzer" story.
- So, considering all that, what are some reasons to quit writing novels?
- Doing so would make me stop feeling like I have two jobs. I love my day job--teaching at a university and currently being the Chair of the Department--and it takes up enormous amounts of time. And then on days off, I tell my wife I'll be up in the office writing for three hours. I could, you know, do other stuff.
- I would stop obsessing about Amazon numbers.
- Reading popular thrillers without being jealous or picking each sentence apart. Having fun reading without the added burden of writing.
- No more AWP conferences.
- There's no money, not for me, not yet. For the print books, I put the whole advances and then some back into "touring"--meaning, going to bookstores that, except for four or five of them, could give a shit that I was there. But now, at least, with the e-books I get to keep a lot more of the dough, but it's not really a life changing sort of number. It's more like a month-changing or week-changing number, but then a few weeks later, right back to where you were. And it's not a lust for money or riches I'm talking about. It's security. It's making sure the family is taken care of. It's about seeing something tangible that I can point to and say, "This means a lot of people really enjoyed that novel I wrote, and I now have the security and confidence to write more."
- Fatigue.
- Really, you spend a year on the damn things when you add in revision. A whole year on a story I really want to share with as many people as possible.
- Numbers. Let's say, being generous, I've got between 5K and 10K readers. That's such a small fraction of the book buyers in this country, right? And consider those 5-10K are spread around the world, well...and that's being generous. How many books am I willing to buy retail because I really like an author and want them to be able to keep doing what they do? Not so much when I want a lot of books on a limited budget. So them how many of my 5-10K (again, being generous) are willing to do the same to keep me rolling? Of course, that's less of a concern if more than 10K people read your books. But what is the threshold for making a living at this? I don't need to make a living at it, since I like what I do, but just curious: what does it take to write novels full-time with a sense of security?
- You know, I came close a couple of times. An editor at one larger press really liked Yellow Medicine and had to take it to her bosses. But the bosses didn't like it. And then, it sounded like we had an offer from one solid press for All the Young Warriors if I was willing to make a few changes. Of course I was happy to make those changes. I would be willing, sure. And then it was quiet for three weeks...before the editor came back and said they'd changed their minds or some such. Yeah, that heartbreak is enough to make you want to quit.
- I hear you saying, "Being that close would just make me want to try harder!" Yeah, well, tell that to the person who came in fourth at the Olympics. Twice.
- I also hear you saying, "A true novelist would never even consider quitting. A real writer wouldn't even think about it." Well, to you I say calm the fuck down and realize how wrong you are. Everyone who loves something like writing or golfing or playing in a band or painting or acting or growing flowers or inventing or cooking, everyone has considered just giving it the fuck up at one point.
- Also, the reasons to quit outnumber the reasons not to.
- But I keep doing it. I keep writing novels. I want to, even when I don't.
- Hard to explain, and I don't have any real inspirational advice, nothing like that. Writing crime novels is hard. Trying to find people who want to read them is harder. I do it because I can't imagine not doing it anymore. That's about it.
- I'm waiting for The Baddest Ass to come out, my third Billy Lafitte novel. I'd like to write about him some more, maybe. I'd like more people to want to read about him.
- I just sent in a novel featuring some characters from All the Young Warriors. I don't know if anyone will want to read about them, but I wanted to write about them some more.
- I've got the next James Lee Burke novel on order from Amazon. I'm really looking forward to its arrival. I think I'll really enjoy reading it.
- I'll bet James Lee Burke wanted to quit writing novels a few times, too. If not, well, now I'm just ashamed.